Jump directly to the content

LOVE Island All Stars fans think they've come up with a brand new theory about why Elma Pazar and Ekin-Su are feuding - and it's nothing to do with Curtis Pritchard.

Last night things took another turn when Curtis, 29, overheard Elma, 32, talk about him on the terrace, where she blamed him for the fall-out.

Harriett from Love Island looking pensive.
5
Fans think they have worked out why Elma Pazar REALLY doesn't like Ekin-SuCredit: Rex
Screenshot of Curtis Pritchard on Love Island using his phone.
5
Curtis heard Elma blaming him for the fall-out between the two womenCredit: ITV
From ITV..Love Island All Stars SR2 Ep32: on ITV2 and ITVX..Pictured: ELMA, EKIN...This photograph is (C) ITV plc and can only be reproduced for editorial purposes directly in connection with the programme or event mentioned above, or ITV plc. This photograph must not be manipulated [excluding basic cropping] in a manner which alters the visual appearance of the person photographed deemed detrimental or inappropriate by ITV plc Picture Desk. This photograph must not be syndicated to any other company, publication or website, or permanently archived, without the express written permission of ITV Picture Desk. Full Terms and conditions are available on the website www.itv.com/presscentre/itvpictures/terms..For further information please contact:.michael.taiwo1@itv.com
5
Elma and Ekin-Su have been feuding for weeksCredit: ITV

Things have been going from bad to worse between the two women ever since the Heart Rate Challenge, where Ekin "pecked" Elma's man Sammy on the lips.

Things then took a turn last night, when Elma then decided to blame her rival's man Curtis for their fall-out.

In a conversation with Gabby and Catherine about having another row with Ekin-Su the day before, Elma was unaware she's within in hearing distance of Curtis.

Elma was venting after being told by Catherine that Ekin-Su thinks she's deflecting her anger onto her because issues with Sammy Root.

READ MORE ALL STARS

However, she explained: "It was never about Ekin, it’s Curtis. He’s been tested and he failed and that’s the bottom line of it.” 

However, fans disagree with this, and think that Elma has never liked Ekin-Su because she is "jealous of her talent".

Last night the Islanders took part in a talent show and Ekin smashed it with her piano performance.

Fans now think Elma might be "jealous"; of her nemesis.

Taking to social media one said: "Wow Ekin came, saw and SLAYED with that performance.

"Suddenly all Elma’s hatred is making sense.

Love Island All Stars fans turn on villa favourite as they brand her ‘two faced’ for stirring up feud

"She’s jealous of Ekin as the only one with any talent in there - apart from Curtis."

While this one echoed this: "I think Elma is secretly jel of Ekin, and that piano performance would not have helped!"

ONGOING FEUD

Elma and Ekin-Su's fall-out began during the heart rate challenge.

The Turkish actress chose to give Sammy a peck on the lips as she worked to get his pulse racing.

Ekin-Su Culculoglu and Curtis Pritchard in a scene from Love Island: All Stars.
5
Fans say Curtis is not to blame for the fall-outCredit: Rex
Woman playing a keyboard outdoors.
5
They think Elma is 'jealous' of Ekin-SueCredit: Rex

Ekin then accused Elma of holding a "weird grudge" against her.

The former Celebrity Big Brother star was then left furious in Tuesday night's show when Elma told Curtis Pritchard to "shut the f*** up".

'MEAN GIRL' ACCUSATION

Following another recent clash with Ekin, when she repeatedly told her she was "muggy", Elma was accused of being a "mean girl" by fans.

Again fans vented on social media, with one saying: "Elma is getting really rude now and she’s taking advantage of when she got voted favourite girl."

This one added: "That Elma is turning into a real mean girl. I do not like it!"

Another saying: "Elma is getting really rude now and she’s taking advantage of when she got voted favourite girl."

READ MORE SUN STORIES

This one added: "That Elma is turning into a real mean girl. I do not like it!"

Love Island continues tonight at 9pm on ITV2.

Love Island All Stars 2025 official line-up

Love Island All Stars is back on TV for season 2.

Here we take you through the line-up of all the Islanders who are in the villa so far.

Bombshells

Each series brings with it a string of hot single bombshells making their epic entrance into the villa.

Here's who has joined the villa so far:

Topics