Jump directly to the content

LOVE Island fans have slammed one "two faced" All Star after their conduct following a shock re-coupling ceremony.

It comes after they called out a "feud" centred on the villa's female contingent.

Three women sitting on a couch, discussing a text message.
6
Love Island fans have called out one star's 'two faced' behaviour amid a simmering villa feudCredit: Eroteme
Elma Pazar reacts to a recoupling on Love Island.
6
Some fans called out Catherine for consoling Samie and urging her to follow a connection with Luca - despite being Grace's mateCredit: Eroteme
Elma Pazar reacts to a recoupling on Love Island.
6
Grace was left gutted after she was left single in the latest coupling up ceremonyCredit: Eroteme

Now All Stars regulars are insisting Catherine Agbaje in particular is the ringleader after Grace Jackson appeared isolated from the rest of the bunch.

It came after both Grace, 25, and new bombshell Samie Elishi, 24, were left in tears following the public vote - which paired Luca Bish and Samie together.

This switch-up came just a day after Luca snogged Samie - after the brunette beauty revealed their DMs.

Yet while a host of ITV2 stars flocked around Samie, just Harriett Blackmore, 24, and partner Ronnie Vint, 28, headed to console Grace - who will now be sleeping in her bed alone.

read more love island

One Love Island fan suggested on Instagram: "Catherine one minute being friends with Grace, now all of a sudden she's telling Sammie to put yourself first.

"Cathy is playing chess lol."

A second said: “Really feel for her she really likes him, but all of them going behind her back like that, trying to set Luca up with Samie. That's just two-faced.”

A third then commented: “The way the other girls were actually gunning for Sammy to take Luca, seriously!”

Over on X, fans broadly appeared to share the same view.

One ranted: "Some of these girls are diabolical like Grace literally has no one else except for Harriett bc the rest's attitude in front often her and behind her are questionable like???"

Love Island fans slam Grace over 'rude' attitude towards Luca after he kissed Samie

Another mused: "Why are the girls kinda conspiring against Grace a bit?"

Yet one stuck up for Catherine - who is paired with Omar - and said: "This Catherine commentary is dumb bc she actually consoled both girls.

"And has been there for Grace for time so let’s pipe it down asap."

SAVING GRACE

Previously ITV2 viewers urged Grace to "watch her back" and to "look out for herself" as a result.

Love Island All Stars 2025 official line-up

Love Island All Stars is back on TV for season 2.

Here we take you through the line-up of all the Islanders who are in the villa so far.

Bombshells

Each series brings with it a string of hot single bombshells making their epic entrance into the villa.

Here's who has joined the villa so far:

They also reckon she needs to watch out with Ekin-Su Culculoglu stirring the pot.

All Stars fans have flagged Ekin-Su's behaviour as unacceptable after she sat on the day beds with partner Curtis Pritchard, 28, and tried to carve out some alone time for Samie and Luca.

Fans were quick to accuse the Turkish actress of "stirring the pot" in the process.

Meanwhile, fans have called out the real reason why they believe Ekin-Su is meddling.

READ MORE SUN STORIES

They think she has a game plan as she wants to win Love Island: All Stars.

Taking to X/Twitter, one fan said: "Ekin is totally stirring things up as she just wants to win. Luca and Grace were a strong couple!"

Three Love Island contestants talking on a day bed.
6
While many Islanders consoled Samie, only two headed to GraceCredit: Eroteme
Screenshot of three Love Island contestants reacting to a recoupling.
6
Fans were confused by Catherine's anticsCredit: Eroteme
Elma Pazar crying on Love Island.
6
Samie's first night in the villa ended in tearsCredit: Eroteme
Topics