Jump directly to the content

COUNTRYFILE viewers were enraged by Hamza Yassin’s comments while he was helping to judge photos for their 2024 calendar as they claimed he was “slagging off” contestants. 

In last night’s episode of the BBC agricultural show, the 33-year-old 2022 Strictly winner was joined by Countryfile vet John Craven and Scottish radio DJ Edith Bowman. 

Countryfile viewers were left livid after Hamza and his co-judges "slagged off" photo entries for the 2024 charity calendar
4
Countryfile viewers were left livid after Hamza and his co-judges "slagged off" photo entries for the 2024 charity calendarCredit: BBC
They spent hours judging entries for this year's "WIld Britain" theme
4
They spent hours judging entries for this year's "WIld Britain" themeCredit: BBC

The trio spent hours reviewing entries for Countryfile’s 2024 charity calendar, which has the theme “Wild Britain.”

They were initially thrilled by all the entries for the calendar, which will raise money for Children in Need.

“I’m loving these images. I think they are phenomenal,” Hamza gushed after a couple of hours of judging.

Meanwhile, John, 82, said that the standard of photos “gets better and better every year.” 

READ MORE ON COUNTRYFILE

“We’ve seen hundreds of images that could have made it into the Countryfile calendar,” he added.

John and Hamza really liked one Edith honed onto, which showed gannets flying in and out of the water.

Hamza said: “An image like that made you stop, made you examine it, made you think about it. To me, that’s a beautiful image for us to potentially consider for Wild Britain.”

However, they ultimately didn’t choose that photo. 

Likewise, there was one of two foxes play-fighting in a green field, which viewers really loved, that the judges rejected. “When we first started, we thought this was a pretty good action shot, but we all say no now,” Hamza said. 

The judges continued to be very critical as they narrowed down the final 12 photos.

“It’s certainly getting trickier. I’m finding it harder to pick an image that I like,” Hamza said while he, Edith, and John started turning down more impressive photos.

Edith rejected a vibrant picture of a deer in a forest, saying: “No. I feel like I’ve seen that picture before.”

Meanwhile, Hamza snubbed a black and white photo of waves crashing around a lighthouse. “I like what they were thinking. I just need a bit more drama in the clouds and stuff.”

John then turned down a shot of a beaver in a stream. “It’s not a staggering picture, is it? I think it’s an interesting animal, but the picture isn’t,” he said.

The judges’ criticism didn’t sit right with viewers who took to social media to voice their complaints. 

“I feel sorry for the photographers whose entries they’re slagging off - that’s never been shown before! I like a lot of the rejected ones more than those that made the final 12,” said one disappointed viewer.

“Wow, Countryfile choosing the 12 viewers’ photos for 2024 calendar - I’m sure it’s a hard decision but showing pics to camera and then dismissing them with sneering comments as not suitable for inclusion is a bit harsh!” another commented.

The final 12 photos Hamza, Edith, and John picked are impressive images, but viewers were still livid that some of the beautiful ones shown earlier were not chosen. 

“All that deliberation and they’ve chosen some naff photos for the calendar,” a third viewer said.

“Once again there’s a few in the Countryfile calendar final 12 that are nowhere near as interesting as ones they passed over,” added a fourth.

READ MORE SUN STORIES

“The final 12 photos that they’ve chosen for the 2024 calendar are a bit disappointing. There were definitely better photos that they said no to,” a fifth viewer agreed.

“Really quite disappointed there by the final selection,” a sixth viewer piled on. “The sheep up the mountain looking at the photographer was much better than the one chosen and the same with the foxes. The blue tit reflection shot was amazing but didn’t make it either.”

BBC viewers were not impressed by the judges' "harsh " comments this year
4
BBC viewers were not impressed by the judges' "harsh " comments this yearCredit: BBC
Hamza reunited with Countryfile star John Craven for the first time since his 2022 Strictly win
4
Hamza reunited with Countryfile star John Craven for the first time since his 2022 Strictly winCredit: PA
Topics