with the new fiances.
The comedian asked the pair about their eye colors, favorite foods, best friends, and their biggest phobias.
The game became more intimate when David asked the "grand finale" question about Katie and Blake's sex life.
"Over the course of your short-ish relationship how many times have you made whoopie?" he asked.
"Your answer has to be less than 100 off," he joked, adding: "Make sex and making love both count."
After a tense moment, Katie displayed her answer first, as she claimed they've been together intimately "43 times."
"No chance!" David shouted in response, saying: "I hope that vibrator is in the trash."
Blake then revealed his own answer which read "30" and the crowd broke out in laughter at the raunchy game.
Bachelorette Katie Thurston slams Greg Grippo as a 'LIAR' who 'used her for exposure' after he hid acting past from her