ended up going on a date with each of the boys - with Aaron Francis particularly catching her eye.
But before she "stole" one of the boys - leaving the fate of one of the girls in the balance - ITV cut away.
A teaser for Wednesday's episode then aired, with voiceover man Iain Stirling saying "someone's in for a shock" as a text message sound played.
Bombshell Chloe has 'stolen' one of the boys Credit: ITV Chloe was ready to reveal who she had chosen on Tuesday's episode Credit: ITV The Islanders were shown giving a shocked reaction - with many of them left with open mouths.
Fans cracked the twist last night, and guessed who would be sent packing.
One person said: "I assume the twist is that they have to send someone home and it’ll probably be Hugo"
Another added: "tomorrow’s ‘twist’ is just gonna be them finding out there’s a dumping on Friday this series is so DRY"
However, one person suggested Chloe will pick one of the girls rather than a man: "Plot twist shes gonna choose a girl...."
Another said: "plot twist she choose a girl"
Bombshell Chloe Burrows was supposed to reveal which of the men she wanted to couple up with, which would leave one of the other women single and sent home packing.
The tension around her decision had been building up since she was introduced at the end of the premiere episode in a shocking twist.
The marketing exec , 25, was sent in to stir up trouble in the villa and gets her shocking orders, receiving a text saying she would be the villa villain .
In Tuesday's episode, Love Island viewers watched as Chloe went on a solo date with all the boys as the other girls were stuck back at the villa.
She then spent her first full day at the villa chatting individually to all of the guys - with Aaron Francis catching her eye.
Chloe addressed the Islanders, telling them "I've chosen this boy to couple up with because when I first saw him I thought he was absolutely gorgeous.
"Even though we've not spent much time together at all, the time we did spend, I thought was just so fab."
🌴 Read all the latest Love Island news
Chloe was just about to reveal who she is coupling with Credit: ITV She continued: "I think the most important thing is that you made me feel really comfortable, which was number one thing going in.
"I'm just looking forward to getting to know you on a one to one basis. So the boy I'm looking forward to coupling up with is..."
But then the episode drew to a close with Chloe's choice not aired, but ITV2 teasing drama for tomorrow's episode, and fans were not happy.
Love Island day 2 recap - Catch up on all the action as the couples spend their first full day together