Revealed
Fifa knows best?

Manchester United v Manchester City: The derby combined XI, based on Fifa 17 ratings

SunSport have already had their say on the strongest composite line-up, but what do the stats say according to game

SUNSPORT have had their say on the ultimate combined Manchester derby XI... But do the stats agree?

And by stats, I mean the all-powerful footballing gods of Fifa 17.

Advertisement
Pep Guardiola and Jose Mourinho will be back in opposing dugouts for the 17th timeCredit: Getty Images

Ahead of the eagerly-anticipated showdown between Jose Mourinho and Pep Guardiola, I mean, Manchester United and Manchester City, SunSport takes a look at which stars get the nod.

For the following XI, any unavailable players have been left benched... Which is bad news for City front-man Sergio Aguero who, despite his 89 rating, will be suspended for the clash at Old Trafford.

The Argentine forward is serving the first of a three-game ban following his elbow on West Ham defender Winston Reid before the international break.

RELATED STORIES

TEMPLEGATE'S TIPS
My NAP is a Cheltenham Festival contender way better than this lot
Match and sniff
Bizarre moment Fernandez gives fan his SHORTS… and supporter SNIFFS them
DEADLINE DAY
Window slams SHUT as Spurs ANNOUNCE Tel, Man City SIGN £50m Gonzalez
MAD MOVE
'Only good thing he's done today' joke Chelsea fans as Madueke KNOCKS OVER referee

 

Advertisement

GK: David De Gea (90) - Man United

David De Gea is one of two 90-rated players in the Manchester combined XICredit: Getty Images

FIRST up is one of only two 90+ rated players in the Premier League, United stopper De Gea.

The Spaniard is the obvious choice to take the No1 spot in the derby XI, with Claudio Bravo expected to be around the 83-rated mark as he was on Fifa 16.

RB: Bacary Sagna (81) - Man City

Bacary Sagna gets the nod over Pablo Zabaleta in the all-Manchester Fifa 17 XICredit: Getty Images
Advertisement

FRENCH defender Sagna gets takes the right-back spot in the all-Manchester XI rather simply.

The City man is expected to preserve his place over the ageing Pablo Zabaleta for City, while United have been relient on winger Antonio Valencia to do a job in defence.

CB: Nicolas Otamendi (85) - Man City

Nicolas Otamendi is expected to be handed an 85 rating in the latest FifaCredit: PA:Press Association

WITH Vincent Kompany, 86-rated, injured for the derby, it is up to Nicolas Otamendi to take the first centre-back spot in the derby team.

Advertisement

The Argentine ace is due to be dished out a whopping 85 rating, so his selection is a no-brainer.

CB: Chris Smalling (85) - Man United

Chris Smalling makes the XI with an 85 rating in the absence of Vincent KompanyCredit: PA:Press Association

UNITED man Smalling will join Otamendi as an 85-rated player on Fifa 17... Beating £47.5million-man John Stones.

The England man's rating eclipses that of Phil Jones, Daley Blind and Stones - and goes straight into the Manchester XI.

Advertisement

LB: Luke Shaw (80) - Man United

Luke Shaw has the potential to be one of the best left-backs in the leagueCredit: Getty Images

ONE of the tougher decisions in the XI was who to choose over Shaw or Gael Clichy.

Both were rated at around the same level on last year's edition - and this year is expected to be no different.

Shaw gets the nod this time as he proved in a brief spell before his horror injury last season that he has the potential to be one of the world's top full-backs.

Advertisement

CDM: Ilkay Gundogan (85) - Man City

Ilkay Gundogan may finally don his Man City shirt after being sidelined by injuryCredit: Reuters

PERHAPS the most controversial pick on the list, Gundogan is not expected to start the clash at Old Trafford as he ramps up his return from injury.

But with the German back in training - twinned with his high 85 rating - he's too good a player to turn down...

RCM: Paul Pogba (88) - Man United

Paul Pogba makes the Fifa 17, all Manchester XI with an impressive 88 ratingCredit: PA:Press Association
Advertisement

FOR £109m, you'd better believe Mourinho will be playing Pogba in every game possible... And so will we.

The dynamic French midfielder has an 88 rating on the 2016-17 edition of Fifa and is the first name in the midfield ranks, here.

LCM: David Silva (87) - Man City

Spanish maestro David Silva can look forward to his 87 rating in Fifa 17Credit: PA:Press Association

SPANISH star Silva has been enjoying himself in a deeper role this season and will line up alongside Pogba in the middle of the park.

Advertisement

The midfielder's 87 rating more than justifies his inclusion; it's even good enough for the Premier League top 20, at No12.

RW: Henrikh Mkhitaryan (85) - Man United

Henrikh Mkhitaryan still has plenty to prove at Man United after slow startCredit: Getty Images

HE'S failed to nail down a starting spot in the starting XI thus far, but Mkhitaryan is rumoured to be rated 85 on Fifa 17.

The Armenian will no doubt be a force to be reckoned with at Old Trafford, so he gets the nod here.

Advertisement

LW: Kevin De Bruyne (88) - Man City

Kevin De Bruyne has been in scintillating form through the past 12 monthsCredit: PA:Press Association

HE'S been playing the No10 role all season so far, to great effect, but you just can't leave De Bruyne out.

The Belgian will take the left, attacking midfield berth with a sky-high rating of 88 in the latest edition of the video game franchise.

ST: Zlatan Ibrahimovic (90) - Man United

Zlatan Ibrahimovic, rated 90 in Fifa 17, has enjoyed a superb start to life at Man UnitedCredit: Getty Images
Advertisement

WE end where we started, with the other of just two 90-rated stars in the Manchester teams, with the final spot going to that man Ibrahimovic.

The Swede star has netted three goals in just three Premier League games so far this term and is a no-brainer to make the all-Manchester XI here.

Just imagine how strong a front-line there could have been had Aguero (89) not had a rush of blood to the head...

RESULT

MAN UNITED 6 MAN CITY 5

So United win this round... Now have your say on whether you think Mourinho or Guardiola had a better summer in the transfer market in our poll.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Topics
Advertisement
machibet777.com