Rishi Sunak fights to save Rwanda plan as right-wing Tories brand it an ‘incomplete solution’ ahead of showdown vote
It sets up make-or-break 24 hours for Mr Sunak who has staked his premiership on salvaging the policy and getting flights off the ground
RISHI Sunak’s Rwanda plan was on a knife-edge today after right-wing Tories gave it the thumbs down just hours before a crucial vote.
A “Star Chamber” of lawyers acting for hardline MPs said the legislation was a “partial and incomplete solution” to stopping future removals being thwarted in the courts.
Rebel ringleader Mark Francois urged Mr Sunak to “pull” the Bill and “start again” because there were “so many holes”.
Downing Street hit back this afternoon by publishing their legal advice which makes clear breaking international law would be “alien to the UK’s constitutional tradition of liberty and justice”.
Ministers said small boats price tag could quadruple to £11billion a year if Rwanda does not get off the ground.
It came after five Conservative caucuses on the right of the party demanded the PM hardens up the Bill ahead of the first Commons showdown tomorrow night.
Downing Street has so far been adamant any toughening would see Rwanda pull out of the flagship removal scheme and spell curtains for the plan.
READ MORE ON POLITICS
It sets up make-or-break 24 hours for Mr Sunak who has staked his premiership on salvaging the policy and getting flights off the ground.
The Star Chamber gave its verdict at a meeting of like minded Tory factions this afternoon: the European Research Group, the Common Sense Group, the New Conservatives, the Northern Research Group and the Conservative Growth Group.
Dubbed the “Five Families”, they have enough members to kill Mr Sunak’s Rwanda Bill in the Commons tomorrow night when the legislation has its “second reading”.
The last time a government was defeated at second reading – where MPs vote on the principle of the proposals – was in 1986, and a repeat would spark a crisis for the PM.
Following the meeting, ERG chair Mark Francois said: “In summary, the Bill provides a partial and incomplete solution to the problem of legal challenges in the UK courts being used as stratagems to delay and defeat the removal of illegal migrants to Rwanda.”
New Conservatives leader Danny Kruger added: “The decision for all of us is whether there’s the possibility of improving the Bill so it does meet the expectations we all have.”
And Conservative Growth Group chair Simon Clarke called the verdict “very concerning”.
A further meeting is coming at 6pm where right-wing Tories will hear from former Immigration Minister Robert Jenrick, who quit over the “weak” plan.
The Sun has heard that Mr Sunak has invited the powerbrokers of the factions into No10 tomorrow for a breakfast charm offensive.
Mr Sunak needs to stop 29 MPs rebelling, or 53 abstaining, as that would torpedo the plan.
He published the legal advice of the Rwanda Bill this afternoon making clear the scope for appeals was very small.
And focusing minds on the importance of stopping the boats, he released modelling showing: “The government estimates that if illegal immigration goes unaddressed, the costs of asylum accommodation alone could increase to £32 million per day by 2026 – equivalent to £11 billion per year.”
A Tory civil war broke out following the resignation of Mr Jenrick, who said the legislation needed to be hardened.
While it disapplies elements of the Human Rights Act, it does not completely overrule it and also the European Convention on Human Rights MPs like Suella Braverman wanted.
The Star Chamber said: “Very significant amendments” to the legislation are needed.
It added: “The Prime Minister may well be right when he claims that this is the ‘toughest piece of migration legislation ever put forward by a UK Government’, but we do not believe that it goes far enough to deliver the policy as intended.”