Jump directly to the content

BRUSSELS will be able to legally keep Britain locked into a customs union with the EU forever, secret legal advice has revealed today.

Even if both parties believe that the talks have completely broken down on a trade deal, then Britain will have to stay tied to the bloc to prevent a hard border in Ireland, today's bombshell dossier shows.

 The bombshell legal advice published today says Britain won't be able to get out of the backstop
6
The bombshell legal advice published today says Britain won't be able to get out of the backstopCredit: AFP or licensors

The legal advice ministers tried to keep a secret from MPs has finally been published this morning, giving a damning verdict on the PM's deal with the EU.

After a humiliating defeat in the Commons last night where ministers were found to be in contempt for the first time ever, they finally agreed to make it public.

MPs voted to defy the Government and release the full documents - rather than just a summary.

Buried in the small text it confirms that even if Britain is still negotiating with the EU years later and both parties think talks have broken down, then the UK still can't get out of the customs union backstop.

 Attorney General Geoffrey Cox's advice says the Irish backstop plan could keep Britain indefinitely in a customs union
6
Attorney General Geoffrey Cox's advice says the Irish backstop plan could keep Britain indefinitely in a customs unionCredit: AFP or licensors
 Yesterday she confirmed ministers would bow to pressure and publish the legal advice in full
6
Yesterday she confirmed ministers would bow to pressure and publish the legal advice in fullCredit: AFP or licensors

It says: "In international law the protocal would endure indefinitely until a superceding agreement took its place, in whole or in part."

And it went on to say: "The protocal is intended to subsist even when negotiations have clearly broken down."

The legal advice also blasted Mrs May's claims that a review of the situation could get us out of it.

The small print read it "does not provide for a mechanism that is likely to enable the UK lawfully to exit the UK wide customs union without a subsequent agreement".

It said that because there was no right to end the backstop, there was a "legal risk that the UK might become subject to protracted and repeating rounds of negotiations".

And the legal advice also caused a fresh headache for Mrs May's Northern Ireland allies, the DUP.

The notes today said that goods travelling between Great Britain to Northern Ireland "will be subject to a declaration process", it added, saying "GB is essentially treated as a third country by NI for goods..."

Regulatory checks would have to take place at airports or ports - but the EU did say that many of these could take place away from the border.

The DUP's Nigel Dodds, who has said his party and 10 MPs won't support the PM in Government if the deal passes, said: "No wonder they tried to hide the legal advice. Devastating advice from AG."

He said the text proved that "Northern Ireland would be in full EU customs union while GB is not" - putting in a barrier between Northern Ireland and the rest of the country.

 Extracts of the letter of legal advice Attorney General gave to the PM
6
Extracts of the letter of legal advice Attorney General gave to the PM
 It concluded that there was a huge risk in getting trapped in a customs union with the EU forever
6
It concluded that there was a huge risk in getting trapped in a customs union with the EU forever
WATCH LIVE: Parliament debates Theresa May's Brexit deal

And Lib Dem Brexit spokesperson Tom Brake blasted: “Nobody voted for Britain to be trapped in a Brexit hamster wheel, constantly haggling with close partners on trade as the country gets poorer."

Today Commons leader Andrea Leadsom said MPs will live to "regret" forcing the Government into publishing it.

It was just one of three votes Theresa May's administration lost last night.

The news comes as:

But Ms Leadsom said this morning: "I think any parliamentarian who wants at some point in the future to be in Government is going to live to regret their vote last night."

She said it undermined "decades if not centuries of convention" where ministers were able to receive advice in secret.

And she would only back Mrs May as PM "at the moment".

The Prime Minister will face PMQs in the Commons later today, followed by the continuation of the debate on her Brexit deal.

MPs will have their crunch vote on it next week - where the PM is all but certain to lose.

 Theresa May suffered three humiliating defeats over Brexit last night
6
Theresa May suffered three humiliating defeats over Brexit last nightCredit: Getty Images - Getty

Ms Leadsom said today that if the PM's deal was thrown out in the vote next week, Britain would leave without a deal.

Other MPs are determined to stop that happening, saying there's no majority for that to pass in the Commons.

"Unless government were to do something completely different to change tack, or indeed to pass this deal, then we will be leaving the EU on 29 March next year without a deal, so it defaults to no deal," Ms Leadsom said this morning.

Last night MPs won the power to block No Deal and call a second referendum if the PM lost the vote.

Piers Morgan gets in bust-up with top Brexiteer Dominic Raab on Good Morning Britain


  • GOT a story? RING The Sun on 0207 782 4104 or WHATSAPP on 07423720250 or EMAIL [email protected]

 

 

Topics