Jump directly to the content

JUSTICE minister Dr Phillip Lee has dramatically resigned to oppose the Government's Brexit policy - comparing it to the death penalty.

Theresa May was dealt the blow by her close ally just hours before a series of crucial votes in the House of Commons on her flagship EU withdrawal bill.

 Dr Phillip Lee has resigned as Justice minister over the Government's Brexit policy
6
Dr Phillip Lee has resigned as Justice minister over the Government's Brexit policyCredit: UK Parliament

Remain-backing Dr Lee said he was standing down "so that I can better speak up for my constituents", saying he wants to vote to give MPs more say over the final deal the UK gets back from Brussels.

He has now explained his decision in the chamber, saying it was a "matter of deep principle".

The MP for Bracknell said: "A Government’s first repsonsbilty is to protect its citizens. This is usually understood in military terms but I believe it applies more generally.

“It means that sometimes when a majority of our people want something that is against the good of society, government and parliament has a responsibility to protect us.

Dr Phillip Lee resigned while giving a speech at the Bright Blue think tank

“This was the case with the death penalty, when for decades politicians went against the majority view and refused to reinstate it.

“Now I believe it needs to be the case with the Brexit process.”

Dr Lee backed Mrs May's bid to become PM in 2016, and was made a minister in the wake of her victory.

But their relationship goes back much further, as Dr Lee was a guest at her wedding, and is seen as one of her few real friends in politics.


What we know so far:


 Theresa May told MPs they must think of the nation in a desperate appeal for unity among her feuding party
6
Theresa May told MPs they must think of the nation in a desperate appeal for unity among her feuding partyCredit: PRU

So his decision to turn on her plan for Brexit today, and also call for the public to have another vote on the EU deal, will be all the more damaging.

The PM was reportedly only given a few minutes warning before she went into chair a Cabinet meeting of his plan to resign on stage at a think tank.

Dr Lee said this afternoon: "I believe that there is growing evidence which shows that the Brexit policy our Government is currently pursuing to deliver on the 2016 referendum is detrimental to the people we were elected to serve."

By resigning from the government he is free to vote against it this afternoon, when the PM faces a fight to take back control of her key legislation.

The House of Lords passed a series of amendments aimed at wrecking the bill, which outlines how we will exit the EU, last month.

 Dr lee resigned while giving a speech at the Bright Blue think tank this morning
6
Dr lee resigned while giving a speech at the Bright Blue think tank this morningCredit: WeAreBrightBlue

Mrs May is hoping to overturn all 15 of them during two days of debate starting this afternoon.

Opening the exchanges, David Davis said that MPs should reject anything that seeks to threaten the vote or undermine it.

But pro-EU Tory MPs have threatened to defy him on some of the clauses in a bid to force the UK into a softer Brexit or give them more control over it.

The amendment where the PM faces the most difficulty is on giving the Commons a so-called "meaningful vote".

This would allow MPs the chance to not only vote on whether they are happy with the final Brexit deal, but allows them to direct ministers to go back and renegotiate.

 Dominic Grieve, left, with fellow Tory rebels Anna Soubry and Ken Clarke, has seen his compromise on a 'meaningful vote' rejected by No10
6
Dominic Grieve, left, with fellow Tory rebels Anna Soubry and Ken Clarke, has seen his compromise on a 'meaningful vote' rejected by No10Credit: PA

The government offered their own version of the amendment last week, watering it down, but that was rejected by the rebels.

And this morning the leader of the pro-EU Tories, Dominic Grieve, tabled another version of the amendment as a potential compromise and head off any defeat for the PM.

But Number 10 has rejected this plan, saying it goes to far in giving MPs control over the direction of the Brexit talks, suggesting the vote today will now go down to the wire.

And the rebels can count one more to their ranks as of this morning, following Dr Lee's shock resignation.

What does the resignation mean for Theresa May?

THE JUSTICE minister Dr Philip Lee’s resignation just hours before the votes on the Brexit bill gives the PM a serious headache.

The 47-year-old supported Mrs May when she ran for Number 10 having been a close friend, even attending her wedding, and was rewarded with a junior position in Government.

So his decision to quit at a crucial moment is a blow for the idea of Government unity, and could trigger more to stand down.

Dr Lee has made no secret of his support for remaining in the EU, and has threatened to resign in the past.

But the fact that he has now pulled the trigger means he is free to vote against Mrs May in today’s withdrawal bill debate.

With no majority in Parliament the PM faces a knife-edge outcome, and the addition of one more rebel could be crucial.

Downing Street has rejected a compromise on giving MPs a “meaningful vote” on the final deal, but this decision could force them to think again about accepting it for fear of losing the vote.

The 47-year-old, who has been a minister since the summer of 2016, explained his decision in a statement on his website.

He said it "goes against every grain in my soul", but was something he had to do "because, for me, such a serious principle is being breached that I would find it hard to live with myself afterwards if I let it pass".

The MP explained: "The main reason for my taking this decision now is the Brexit process and the Government's wish to limit Parliament's role in contributing to the final outcome in a vote that takes place today.

"If, in the future, I am to look my children in the eye and honestly say that I did my best for them I cannot, in all good conscience, support how our country's exit from the EU looks set to be delivered."

He also revealed support for holding another referendum on the Brexit deal, writing: "When the Government is able to set out an achievable, clearly defined path - one that has been properly considered, whose implications have been foreseen, and that is rooted in reality and evidence, not dreams and dogma - it should go to the people, once again, to seek their confirmation."

 Already facing a knife-edge vote, the decision by her former backer Dr Lee is a blow to the PM
6
Already facing a knife-edge vote, the decision by her former backer Dr Lee is a blow to the PMCredit: EPA

However he could also face the threat of being deselected by his local party, after the chairman of the constituency - which voted 54 per cent for Leave - called for him to explain his decision at a meeting on Monday.

And Chris Boutle told The Telegraph “if an election were to be called it will count again him” if he wanted to be chosen again as the party's candidate.

However he has been supported in his decision by several MPs, with Labour’s Chris Bryant calling him a “man to admire and respect”.

And the Shadow Education Secretary Angela Rayner tweeted: “This has got to be one of the hardest decisions a government minister would take so I have total respect to him for standing by what he thinks is right regardless of which side of the debate you are on.”

 Dr Lee has been supported by both Labour and Tory MPs for his decision
6
Dr Lee has been supported by both Labour and Tory MPs for his decisionCredit: PA

The Tory former minister Nick Boles also posted: “I don't agree with Dr Phillip Lee about the idea of holding a referendum on the Brexit deal.

"But I admire his honesty and integrity.”

And he seemingly made a dig at David Davis, who threatened to, but ultimately stopped short of, resigning as Brexit Secretary last week over the Irish border backstop.

Mr Boles added: “So much classier to resign on principle when nobody is expecting it, than to threaten resignation but never follow through.”

Piers Morgan calls on MPs to 'sort it out' ahead of Brexit vote and rows with Susanna Reid over whether Donald Trump could get it done

Last night the PM told rebellious Tory MPs to think of the nation in a desperate appeal for unity among her feuding party.

At a meeting with the 1922 committee of backbenchers she said: "We must think about the message Parliament will send to the European Union this week.

"I am trying to negotiate the best deal for Britain.

"I am confident I can get a deal that allows us to strike our own trade deals while having a border with the EU which is as frictionless as possible.

"But if the Lords amendments are allowed to stand, that negotiating position will be undermined."

She added: "The message we send to the country through our votes this week is important.

"We must be clear that we are united as a party in our determination to deliver on the decision made by the British people."

How have meddling peers wrecked Theresa May’s Brexit bill and can she overturn the changes?

The House of Lords has passed 15 amendments to the EU Withdrawal Bill but only a few are expected to make it into law after the Commons has its say- here they all are:

Keeping Britain in the customs union

The first Lords amendment to be passed would force the Government to negotiate with the EU to keep Britain in the customs union after Brexit.

Impact on Brexit: 4/5

Chance of passing: 4/5

EEA membership after Brexit

Perhaps the most damaging amendment for the Government’s Brexit plan is a motion to propel Britain into the European Economic Area.

Impact on Brexit: 5/5

Chance of passing: 2/5

Scrapping exit day

The bill contains a clause stating that Britain MUST leave the EU on March 29 next year, in order to stop ministers backsliding on the exact date of Brexit.

Impact on Brexit: 4/5

Chance of passing: 3/5

Hanging on to EU rights

Peers voted to incorporate the EU’s Charter of Fundamental Rights into British law, as well as the existing Human Rights Act which will be unaffected by Brexit.

Impact on Brexit: 4/5

Chance of passing: 3/5

Keeping the border open to refugees

Lord Dubs, who came to the UK as a child refugee, wrote an amendment which requires the Government to maintain current rules on refugees.

Impact on Brexit: 3/5

Chance of passing: 3/5

Beheading Henry VIII

The Lords want to restrict the Government to use so-called Henry VIII powers to push through technical details of Brexit without holding a vote of Parliament only when "necessary”.

Impact on Brexit: 2/5

Chance of passing: 4/5

Final say for Parliament

The Lords voted to give Parliament a "meaningful vote" on the terms of Britain's withdrawal deal, taking the final say away from ministers.

Impact on Brexit: 2/5

Chance of passing: 4/5

Protecting the Good Friday Agreement

One amendment is designed to preserve peace in Northern Ireland by upholding the terms of the Good Friday Agreement.

Impact on Brexit: 2/5

Chance of passing: 4/5

Staying in touch with Europe

An amendment introduced by the Bishop of Leeds ensures that Britain can choose to mirror EU laws and stay a member of specific European agencies after Brexit.

Impact on Brexit: 1/5

Chance of passing: 5/5

More scrutiny on the details

Peers voted to expand the role of the "sifting committee"; which examines how ministers make technical amendments to existing laws.

Impact on Brexit: 1/5

Chance of passing: 4/5

EU regulations enshrined in law

One of the Lords amendment aims to keep European laws on employment, health and safety, and the environment on Britain's statute book for good.

Impact on Brexit: 4/5

Chance of passing: 2/5

Curbs on ministers' powers

Lib Dem peer Lord Beith managed to win an amendment which ties ministers' hands on future changes to the law.

Impact on Brexit: 3/5

Chance of passing: 1/5

Overturning laws which defy EU

The EU Withdrawal Bill states that the general principles behind European law should be transferred into British law after Brexit.

Impact on Brexit: 3/5

Chance of passing: 1/5

Handing MPs a veto over talks

One of the most radical amendments would force ministers to get the permission of Parliament before negotiating the terms of Britain's future trade with the EU.

Impact on Brexit: 4/5

Chance of passing: 1/5

Green laws remain in place

The final Lords amendment, passed on Wednesday night, would enshrine Europe's environmental principles in British law.

Impact on Brexit: 3/5

Chance of passing: 2/5

Topics