We investigate the real difference between natural, processed and ultra-processed foods
You might think opting for that low-fat ready meal or oven chips is better than picking up the phone and calling your local takeaway - but scientists have revealed you could actually be increasing your risk of cancer
YOU might think you are being good to yourself by opting for a low-fat ready meal or oven chips rather than a takeaway.
But scientists from France have suggested the more such “ultra-processed” foods feature in our diets, the greater our risk of getting cancer.
Ultra-processed foods contain fewer nutrients, less fibre and more sugar, fat and salt – and more additives and preservatives – than processed foods.
But how do you tell the difference?
Here, CHRISTINA EARLE helps by highlighting what is in natural, processed and ultra-processed foods.
POTATOES
Natural
POTATO
We all love a decent spud, which are rich in heart-boosting selenium and potassium. They are at their healthiest when baked or steamed, then served as part of a balanced meal.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
TINNED BASICS SAINSBURY’S POTATOES (540g)
These are good for you but contain firming agents and anti- oxidants to help keep them fresh. Be aware of some varieties that add sugar and salt, too.
INGREDIENTS: 4
Ultra-processed
TESCO HOMESTYLE STRAIGHT CUT OVEN CHIPS (950g)
These include sunflower oil, rice flour, potato starch, turmeric and paprika. If you like chips, it is best to make your own oven-cooked versions.
INGREDIENTS: 9
TURKEY
Natural
TURKEY LEG
Low in fat and high in protein, we should not just wait for Christmas to tuck into a bit of fresh turkey. It is a good source of lean protein, which helps keep our muscles in good shape.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
ASDA WAFER THIN HONEY ROAST TURKEY SLICES
They might sound healthy but these slices consist of only 80 per cent turkey. Sugar also sneaks on to the lengthy ingredients list.
INGREDIENTS: 10
Ultra-processed
BERNARD MATTHEWS BREADED TURKEY ESCALOPES
Just 36 per cent turkey, plus modified waxy maize starch, spirit vinegar and sodium bicarbonate – which Victorians used to clean with.
INGREDIENTS: 19
BEETROOT
Natural
BEETROOT
Good for blood pressure, as they are rich in potassium. They are stuffed with folic acid too, which, along with a 400 microgram daily supplement, helps expectant mothers prevent birth defects.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
ASDA PICKLED CRINKLE CUT BEETROOT
Although beetroot in a jar is not inherently bad for you, it does contain additives and sugar. Best stick to the fully natural stuff for the best health boost.
INGREDIENTS: 8
Ultra-processed
TYRRELL’S VEGETABLE CRISPS WITH MAPLE
Veggie crisps can be worse than potato. Each pack contains a blend of 63 per cent of beetroot, parsnip and carrot but contains 5.5 tsps of sugar per 100g.
INGREDIENTS: 4
PORK
Natural
PORK SHOULDER STEAK
A great source of B vitamins, key to a healthy nervous system and blood. Its high iron content could help stave off anaemia and keep red blood cells healthy.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
WAITROSE DUCHY ORGANIC PORK SAUSAGES
Not as healthy as pork shoulder steak, they contain 86 per cent pork shoulder and ingredients such as wheat and yeast to bulk them out.
INGREDIENTS: 15
Ultra-processed
MORRISONS 20 MINI PORK SAUSAGE ROLLS
Mini sausage rolls contain a tiny 32 per cent pork, plus nasty vegetable oils and potato starch to keep flour fresh. Low in fibre, with added salt.
INGREDIENTS: 16
RASPBERRIES
Natural
RASPBERRY
Packed with skin-boosting vitamins, such as vitamin C. They are also rich in antioxidants which can help ward off cancer and dementia. An 80g portion is one of your five a day.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
TESCO RASPBERRY JAM
Tastes good on your morning toast but contains additional sugars and syrups, making it bad for your teeth, while much of the vitamin C is lost in the processing.
INGREDIENTS: 6
Ultra-processed
BURTONS BISCUITS JAMMIE DODGERS
Real raspberries don’t feature here. Flavoured jam makes up 27 per cent of each biscuit, which are also high in calories, with 77 per 18g biscuit and more than 1 tsp of sugar.
INGREDIENTS: 25
LAMB
Natural
ROAST LAMB
Red meat, such as lamb, is an excellent source of iron in its natural state, which can help reduce risk of iron-deficiency anaemia. It is best to eat it in the form of mince or steak.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
TESCO LAMB & MINT BURGERS
These are certainly better for you than an ultra-processed ready meal but bear in mind these burgers contain only 84 per cent lamb plus a preservative.
INGREDIENTS: 13
Ultra-processed
ASDA SHEPHERD’S PIE
Contains just 20 per cent lamb with potato as the main ingredient. Onions also play a big part in terms of volume but the rest is a free-for-all, including burnt sugar syrup.
INGREDIENTS: 36
EGGS
Natural
EGG
Eggs are high in protein and contain vitamin D, which will help you maintain strong teeth and bones. Some are also rich in essential omega 3 acids, which aid brain health.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
TWO CHICKS LIQUID EGG WHITES
As the name suggests, this has had the yolks removed. A thickener has also been added to make them easier to whisk. They still consist mainly of egg.
INGREDIENTS: 2
Ultra-processed
ASDA SHARING 18 SAVOURY EGG BITES
These contain 14 per cent egg and a tiny fraction of dried egg white. High in fat, with 16g of fat per 100g, and low in fibre, with just 1.7g per 100g.
INGREDIENTS: 35
CHICKEN
Natural
CHICKEN BREAST
Chicken is a great source of lean protein that will help your body build and repair muscle and tissues. Protein from chicken also helps regulate hormones.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
MORRISONS CARVERY ROAST CHICKEN (240g)
Contains a respectable 96 per cent chicken breast – but watch out for the preservatives and salt. Why not slice the proper stuff yourself?
INGREDIENTS: 10
Ultra-processed
BIRDSEYE CRISPY CHICKEN DIPPERS
Just 50 per cent chicken goes into a dipper, with the rest made up of different flours, E numbers and some cholesterol- raising palm oil.
INGREDIENTS: 16
TOMATOES
Natural
TOMATOES
Full of antioxidants which help prevent cancer. They are also rich in vitamin A, crucial for healthy skin, and contain no fat. A portion of seven cherry tomatoes counts towards your five a day.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
DOLMIO BOLOGNESE PASTA SAUCE
This contains 76 per cent tomatoes and 11 per cent tomato paste. But watch for sugar content – there are nearly two teaspoons in a 125g serving.
INGREDIENTS: 11
Ultra-processed
GOODFELLA’S THIN & CRISPY MARGHERITA
Contains tomato purée – but there is no mention of real tomatoes in ingredients. Has a third of your daily salt allowance (2g) if you eat half.
INGREDIENTS: 26
CARROTS
Natural
CARROT
Three tablespoons of chopped uncooked carrots provide around 50 calories and 430 per cent of your vitamin A requirements, which helps keep your eyes healthy.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
MORRISONS CARROT AND CORIANDER SOUP
This contains 45 per cent carrot but is also high in salt. One half of a 300g pot contains 1.8g of salt, which is nearly a third of your recommended intake.
INGREDIENTS: 11
Ultra-processed
TESCO FINEST CARROT CAKE
Looks the business but has just 12 per cent carrot, as well as golden syrup and palm oil. It is high in sugar, with 8½ tsp of sugar per 100g, and just 2.5g of fibre.
INGREDIENTS: 35
RICE
Natural
BROWN RICE
Rich in selenium, this stuff is shown to boost heart health. It is wholegrain, which makes it a rich source of fibre, essential for a healthy digestive system and regular bowel movements.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
VEETEE BASMATI MICROWAVE RICE
Sunflower oil and other additives designed to work as preservatives have also been added to this microwave rice, which contains 97 per cent rice.
INGREDIENTS: 15
Ultra-processed
TESCO HEALTHY LIVING CHICKEN & ASPARAGUS RISOTTO (385g)
Contains extra ingredients, including preservatives and salt to help it last longer – with the latter potentially raising blood pressure.
INGREDIENTS: 29
ORANGES
Natural
ORANGE
A good source of B vitamin folate and an excellent source of vitamin C. Folate is proven to help ward off birth defects in mums-to-be when combined with a dietary supplement.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
ORANGE, MANGO & PASSIONFRUIT JUICE
Around 80 per cent of the juice in this comes from oranges. It loses its fibre when turned into juice so stick with real oranges for your vitamin and nutrient hit.
INGREDIENTS: 3
Ultra-processed
ORANGINA (330ml)
This sparkling drink contains just ten per cent oranges and even that comes from concentrated juice. Sugar content is high too, with 3½ tsp per 330ml bottle.
INGREDIENTS: 13
MILK
Natural
MILK
Your bones and teeth will thank you for a glass, as milk is packed with calcium. It helps ward off brittle bone diseases, such as osteoporosis, especially in women, and can improve heart health.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
LAUGHING COW TRIANGLES
The main ingredient in Laughing Cow Cheese Triangles is milk. But emulsifying salts also feature on the ingredients list, so it is not as pure as the creamy white stuff.
INGREDIENTS: 9
Ultra-processed
BISTO CHEESE SAUCE MIX
Bisto’s cheese sauce mix contains nine per cent cheese powder but is mostly made up of palm oil. It also has four E numbers to enhance its flavour and colour.
INGREDIENTS: 22
MOST READ IN HEALTH
TUNA
Natural
TUNA STEAK
We are advised to eat two portions of oily fish a week – tuna steak is a good place to start. Rich in omega 3 acids, it promotes brain health and can reduce the chances of dementia.
INGREDIENTS: 1
Processed
JOHN WEST TUNA CHUNKS IN SUNFLOWER OIL
The oiliness is lost in the canning process, so while tinned tuna offers a rich source of protein, it is not as good for you as tuna steak.
INGREDIENTS: 3
Ultra-processed
SAINSBURY’S TUNA AND SWEETCORN SANDWICH
This contains just 28 per cent tuna. There is also palm fat and palm oil in there, which can raise bad cholesterol, which is linked to heart disease.
INGREDIENTS: 32
CHANGES KILL OFF BENEFITS
FOODS become ultra- processed when the original ingredients have undergone so many changes to their basic form that they require a bevy of additives to make it into our food chain.
They are often left with little of the original ingredient.
Anything from ready meals and rice cakes to sausages and savoury snacks can be ultra-processed, so check for labelling and “traffic light” information.
If it is not there, the product could have something to hide, so turn them over and check the nutritional numbers.
Anything with more than 3g of fat, 1.5g of saturated fat, 5g of sugars and 0.3g of salt per 100g means you need to think twice.
Try to only eat products with the least number of ingredients — the longer the list, the higher the chance it is ultra-processed.
With the exception of home-grown fruits and veg, technically most food is processed before we eat it. We process food to make it palatable, digestible and safe.
No nutritionist in their right mind is going to turn their nose up at the usefulness of processing such as the pasteurisation of milk, for example.
Try to base your meals and snacks on vegetables, wholegrain starchy carbohydrates — such as porridge oats and brown rice — and lean protein — for example eggs, pulses, chicken and fish.
Include some fruit and some water to keep you hydrated and it is fine to have some ultra-processed foods for a treat.
Rely on them all the time, though, and your diet is likely to take a severe nutritional hit.
By Amanda Ursell
GOT a story? RING The Sun on 0207 782 4104 or WHATSAPP on 07423720250 or EMAIL [email protected]