Jump directly to the content
Investigation
THE RICH TWIST

We expose more than 100 super-rich celebrities including David Beckham, Robbie Williams and Geri Horner involved in £700m tax relief scheme, who could now face even BIGGER tax bills

Pop stars, sporting legends and politicians have been linked to the controversial scheme which HMRC claims was a form of avoiding tax

THE Sun today reveals the names of a vast swathe of super-rich celebrities who cashed in on a controversial tax relief scheme.

More than 100 face bigger tax bills after losing a legal challenge over the £700million plan. The list includes pop stars, sporting legends, TV personalities and politicians.

 Robbie Williams has been linked to the controversial tax relief scheme
12
Robbie Williams has been linked to the controversial tax relief schemeCredit: Getty Images

Among names linked to the controversial film plans which offered tax breaks were Robbie Williams, Phillip Schofield and Victoria and David Beckham.

HM Revenue and Customs argued the scheme was a form of avoidance and won a ruling last August to claw back more than two thirds of the total tax relief claimed.

A ruling this week, revealed by The Sun, upheld the ori­ginal decision and concluded the incentives were not “allowable de­du­c­tions”.

 Both Victoria and David Beckham have been linked to the scheme which HMRC claims to be a form of tax avoidance
12
Both Victoria and David Beckham have been linked to the scheme which HMRC claims to be a form of tax avoidanceCredit: Getty Images
 This Morning host Phillip Schofield was offered a tax break after investing in Ingenious film schemes
12
This Morning host Phillip Schofield was offered a tax break after investing in Ingenious film schemesCredit: Rex Features
 Former Spice Girl Geri Halliwell - now known as Geri Horner - is another celebrity caught up in the scheme
12
Former Spice Girl Geri Halliwell - now known as Geri Horner - is another celebrity caught up in the schemeCredit: Rex Features
 Ex-Man City midfielder Joey Barton is another big name who could now face an even bigger tax bill
12
Ex-Man City midfielder Joey Barton is another big name who could now face an even bigger tax billCredit: PA:Press Association

An appeal is yet to be heard, but more than 100 celebs could now face bigger tax bills as a result.

They were among 1,400 investors who poured cash into the Ingenious “partnerships” which helped produce movies including Avatar and qualified for tax breaks designed to ­support the UK film industry.

But HMRC said Ingenious claimed relief on artificial losses from its films.

That meant the schemes were not legitimate investment opportunities but a means of avoiding tax.

 TV presenter Davina McCall was among one of the 1,400 investors who poured cash into the controversial film plans which offered tax breaks
12
TV presenter Davina McCall was among one of the 1,400 investors who poured cash into the controversial film plans which offered tax breaksCredit: Getty Images - WireImage
 Tory politician Andrew Mitchell also ploughed money into the scheme
12
Tory politician Andrew Mitchell also ploughed money into the schemeCredit: Getty Images
 TV presenters Ant and Dec have also been linked to the controversial tax relief scheme
12
TV presenters Ant and Dec have also been linked to the controversial tax relief schemeCredit: Getty Images
 English cricketer Nasser Hussain - who holds an OBE - also took part in the tax relief scheme
12
English cricketer Nasser Hussain - who holds an OBE - also took part in the tax relief schemeCredit: Getty Images
 Singer Craig David may now a bigger tax bill after the bid to keep his fortune
12
Singer Craig David may now a bigger tax bill after the bid to keep his fortuneCredit: Getty Images - FilmMagic

Others on the list, obtained via Companies House records, include Sir Alex Ferguson, singer Craig David, ex-England manager Stev­e McClaren and Sacha Baron Cohen.

Actor Neil Morrissey was on the list, but reached agreement with HMRC in 2013 and has no outstanding liabilities to pay further tax.

Many of those involved have been knighted or received honours from the Queen. Others are Lords.

Last night a tax source said: “Those investors who chanced their arm by taking this to court may end up paying significantly more in tax as a result of this decision.”

HOW IT WORKS

FINANCE firm Ingenious sold tax-efficient investments in Hollywood films such as Avatar.

Sums invested ranged from £160,000 to over £60million.

Stars expected to benefit from tax breaks introduced in 1997 to support the British film industry.

They were able to claim their outlay as tax relief over a period of 15 years.

Tax had to be paid at the end of the 15 years, but investors could make more money out of the delayed tax payment than they were eligible to pay.

It is not claimed the schemes were doing anything illegal.

Sources said some £420million tax was avoided but, with interest, the to­tal owed would near £700million.

Ingenious said most of the dispu­ted tax bills had already been paid by investors but would be reclaimed from HMRC if it won its appeal.

The tribunal found all but one of Ingenious’s partnerships was legitimately “trading”.

 Pop star Gareth Gates has been linked to the scheme which HMRC dubbed to be a form of tax avoidance
12
Pop star Gareth Gates has been linked to the scheme which HMRC dubbed to be a form of tax avoidanceCredit: Getty Images
 Beeb presenter Anne Robinson has also been identified as a celebrity caught up in the scheme
12
Beeb presenter Anne Robinson has also been identified as a celebrity caught up in the schemeCredit: PA:Press Association

The specific tax positions of the named celebs are unknown and it is not clear how many have settled their claims.

Many Ingenious investors claimed they were wrongly advised to enter the schemes.

An HMRC spokesman said: “We are pleased the tribunal agreed the vast majority claimed in tax relief was simply not due.”

But an Ingenious spokesman said: “We strongly disagree with the tribunal’s clarification.”

There is no su­g­gestion that any of those listed on these pages were involved in any illegality.

LIST OF CELEBRITIES INVOLVED

  • Victoria Beckham
  • Geri Halliwell
  • Melanie Chisholm
  • Simon Fuller
  • Peter Gabriel
  • Phillip Schofield
  • Robbie Williams
  • George Michael
  • Craig David
  • Gareth Gates
  • Ant and Dec
  • Anne Robinson
  • Davina McCall
  • Neil Morrissey
  • David Suchet
  • Sacha Baron Cohen
  • David Heyman
  • Jeremy Paxman
  • Kate Adie
  • Peter Fincham (ex-ITV boss)
  • Lord Grade of Yarmouth (ex-BBC chairman)

LIST OF POLITICIANS INVOLVED

  • Lord Clive Hollick (Labour donor)
  • Lord Davis of Abersoch
  • Andrew Mitchell MP (Tory)
  • Rt Hon Lord Sainsbury (Tory)
  • Lord William Waldegrave (Tory)

LIST OF FOOTBALLERS INVOLVED

  • David Beckham (ex-Man Utd)
  • Dennis Wise (ex-Chelsea)
  • Dean Windass (ex-Hull)
  • Steven Gerrard (ex-Liverpool)
  • Anton Ferdinand (ex-QPR)
  • Marcus Bent (ex-Everton)
  • Jamie Carragher (ex-Liverpool)
  • Nicky Barmby (ex-Spurs)
  • Dominic Matteo (ex-Liverpool)
  • Wes Brown (ex-Man Utd)
  • Nicky Butt (ex-Man Utd)
  • Michael Hughes (ex-C Palace)
  • Steven Caldwell (ex-Burnley)
  • Joey Barton (ex-Man City)
  • Martin Keown (ex-Arsenal)
  • Jonathan Woodgate (ex-Leeds)
  • Colin Hendry (ex-Blackburn)
  • Emile Heskey (ex-Liverpool)
  • Clinton Morrison (ex-Palace)
  • Danny Murphy (ex-Liverpool)
  • Scott Parker (ex-Charlton)
  • John O’Shea (ex-Man Utd)
  • Hayden Mullins (ex-Palace)
  • John Arne Riise (ex-Liverpool)
  • Trevor Sinclair (ex-West Ham)
  • Mamady Sidibe (ex-Stoke)
  • Robbie Keane (ex-Spurs)
  • Neil Lennon (ex-Leicester)
  • Joleon Lescott (ex-Man City)
  • Gary Lineker (ex-Leicester)
  • Paul Konchesky (ex-Leicester)
  • Francis Jeffers (ex-Everton)
  • Eoin Jess (ex-Aberdeen)
  • Alain Goma (ex-Fulham)
  • Ryan Giggs (ex-Man Utd)
  • Andy Griffin (ex-Newcastle)
  • Tim Cahill (ex-Everton)
  • Jussi Jaskelainen (ex-Bolton)
  • Michael Bridges (ex-Leeds)
  • Matthew Etherington (ex-W Ham)
  • Paul McVeigh (ex-Norwich)
  • Gudni Bergsson (ex-Bolton)
  • Simon Charlton (ex-Bolton)
  • Matthew Elliott (ex-Leicester)
  • Dean Richards (ex-Wolves)

LIST OF MANAGERS INVOLVED

  • Steve McClaren (Ex-England)
  • Sir Alex Ferguson (Ex-Man Utd)
  • Carlo Cudicini (Ex-Chelsea assistant)
  • Martin O’Neill (Ex-Rep of Ireland)
  • David O’Leary (Ex-Leeds)
  • Gary McAllister (Ex-Leeds)

LIST OF CRICKETERS INVOLVED

  • Michael Vaughan
  • Marcus Trescothick
  • Matthew Hoggard
  • Nasser Hussain
  • Alec Stewart
  • David Gower
  • Craig White
  • Duncan Fletcher (former England coach)

We erroneously included the newsreader Alastair Stewart in the above list. We apologise to him for this error.

Topics