Jump directly to the content
DOLLY GOSH

Your old My Little Pony could be worth more than £450 – here’s how to cash in

IF you didn't own a My Little Pony toy then the chances are your sister did.

But who knew that those plastic, hollow ponies from the 80s could soon be worth a small fortune.

 If you still own a My Little Pony toy from the 80s then you could be in for a treat
11
If you still own a My Little Pony toy from the 80s then you could be in for a treat

Some My Little Pony toys from the 80s are selling for more than £450 EACH on eBay and they don't even have to be in the box.

Often, vintage toys sell better when they're in mint condition and still in their original packaging but it doesn't seem to matter when it comes to the pony dolls.

It's a franchise that's dominated the toy industry over the past nearly 30 years, even getting its own line of movies, books, TV series and even a cult male following called Bronies.

And thanks to the unique symbols painted on their sides they've become collectables. So it might be time to rummage through your old toy box ...

G1 Spanish Pigg Pony Fresita, £454

 The first generation pony sold for a whopping £450 even though it didn't come in a box
11
The first generation pony sold for a whopping £450 even though it didn't come in a boxCredit: eBay
 It only attracted two bidders and was auctioned earlier this year
11
It only attracted two bidders and was auctioned earlier this yearCredit: eBay

This rare My Little Pony from the 80s has pretty little strawberries on the hinds of the horse, although they're pretty faint now.

The seller listed it as "used" and it didn't come in its original box.

Even though the seller didn't include much more information on the toy's condition, after attracting only two bids.

Vintage G1 My Little Pony Greek Baby Moondancer - £362

 Another first generation horse made in the Greek factory sold for £362
11
Another first generation horse made in the Greek factory sold for £362Credit: eBay
 The Moondancer wasn't in the best condition but still made a small fortune on eBay
11
The Moondancer wasn't in the best condition but still made a small fortune on eBayCredit: eBay

This particular toy was made in the el Graco factory in Greece, which was the only foreign maker licensed by Hasbro.

The Baby Moondancer is a rare toy thanks to her moon and star symbols on her back.

What should you do if you have a valuable My Little Pony toy?

IF you think you’ve got a My Little Pony doll that’s worth a bit extra then you should start by doing your research.

Find out how much your toy is worth to a collector by checking the same or similar My Little Pony dolls under “sold listings”.

Compare your My Little Pony toy to other higher selling auctions and ask yourself if it’s in a similar condition? Is your toy authentic? Does it still have the labels on? Is it still in its original packaging?

If it’s in mint condition then it might be worth selling it through an auction house or directly to a collectibles website. If it’s not, it’s probably worth sticking it on eBay for a moderate sum.

It isn't in the original packaging but the seller did state that it has a "few flaws" like the missing tip of her unicorn and a "tiny bite" on its ear.

Still, despite the imperfections, .

My Little Pony G1 Nurse Pony, £337.99

 The 'Mein Kleines Pony' is from a German seller and was the only one in the top five still in its original packaging
11
The 'Mein Kleines Pony' is from a German seller and was the only one in the top five still in its original packagingCredit: EBay
 Even though the packaging was in German, it still attracted 18 bidders
11
Even though the packaging was in German, it still attracted 18 bidders

This toy was sold by a seller in Germany and was in it's original packaging, despite being listed as "used".

It attracted 18 bids from all over the world. The .

Vintage G1 My Little Pony Greek Ladybird, £322

 The peach coloured Ladybird toy has little painted insects on her hind making her a collectable
11
The peach coloured Ladybird toy has little painted insects on her hind making her a collectableCredit: EBay
 This particular pony was sold from a seller in Greece and fetched more than £320 at auction
11
This particular pony was sold from a seller in Greece and fetched more than £320 at auctionCredit: eBay

This one was also made by el Greco in 1982. If a toy is old than 20 yeas then typically it's considered vintage and therefore more valuable.

How to avoid the dangers of selling your old My Little Pony toys on eBay

SELLING things on eBay can be a big money earner - when you're doing it right. Here are the dangers you need to avoid if you want to make a profit:

  • You need to set a minimum price on your auction. It needs to be higher or at least value to what you're selling, otherwise it could be bought for less than it's worth. This is exactly what happened when someone sold a new £10 note for less than a tenner.
  • Even if your item sells, there's no guarantee the buyer will cough up. When you set up the auction you can opt for the highest bidder to pay straight away.
  • Don't forget that eBay will charge you a sellers fee if you sell your item. If you're selling up to 50 items a month - and you're not a business -  you'll be charged 10 per cent of the sale. Take this into consideration when you're listing your item.

The pony is permanently in a sitting position and in a "good condition".

Even though it didn't come in a box, it.

My Little Pony Baby Beachy Fancy Pants, £273

 The pony is only half of a mother and baby set but still sold for nearly £300
11
The pony is only half of a mother and baby set but still sold for nearly £300Credit: EBay
 Even though the seller included very little detail about the condition of the toy it still sold for £273
11
Even though the seller included very little detail about the condition of the toy it still sold for £273Credit: eBay

This pony was originally part of a mother and baby two set.

According to the seller, this baby horse was is in good condition with "good hair" and "no stains".

There was a bidding war on this one with 25 users fighting to get their hands on it. The at the beginning of the new year.

It's not just your old My Little Ponies that could be worth a fortune nowadays. Your Barbie collection could be worth up to £580 and they don't need to be in the box either.

Remember the ugly Troll Dolls with their wild hair and often stark naked bodies from our childhood? They're selling for up to £200 on eBay too.

And if you're still an owner of an original Polly Pocket toy, you could be in for a surprise because some are selling for up to £7,795 on the auction site.


We pay for your stories! Do you have a story for The Sun Online Money team? Email us at [email protected] or call 0207 78 24516. Don't forget to join the for the latest bargains and money-saving advice.


Topics