CONSUMER CREW

From bagging yourself a open-plan barn conversion to nabbing a free pint – our experts share advice and deals

Every Saturday, The Consumer Crew are here to solve your problems.

Mel Hunter will take on readers’ consumer issues, Amanda Cable will give you the best advice for buying your dream home, Maddy Tooke rounds up the best coupons to save you money and Judge Rinder will tackle your legal woes.

Advertisement

Judge Rinder - The Sun's legal expert

Judge Rinder offers his advice on legal representation

IN my career, I’ve seen an extensive collection of judges, from the grandest Lords Justice of the Court of Appeal to cheerful magistrates in Portakabins plonked next to chip shops.

So when I heard the criticism of the chairman of the Grenfell Tower inquiry, Sir Martin Moore-Bick, it immediately made me think back through all the different kinds I have met.

It seems there are concerns that Sir Martin lacks sympathy or doesn’t do the “right kind” of law.

So I tried to think of a type who might be better for something as important as this.

Advertisement

But in my view, there isn’t one.

In fact, he is exactly the kind of judge this inquiry needs.

Sir Martin Moore-BickCredit: PA:Press Association

Part of the problem seems to be that Sir Martin began in the commercial courts rather than criminal.

Advertisement

A normal case for commercial judges often involves sifting through thousands of pages of evidence.

One day they might have to reconstruct the daily workings of several multi-national corporations; another, decide what two shopkeepers whispered at the back of a warehouse 30 years ago.

Sir Moore-Bick will shine an intense, unsparing light into every dark crevice of the Grenfell Tower tragedy

Some, like Sir Martin, then move on to unscramble the mindboggling legal puzzles that pass through the Court of Appeal.

It is all tough, complicated work. But the problem is, it can make a judge seem pitiless.

Advertisement

When he gives his decision, there is no room for comedy or compassion, only hard analysis of the facts.

But it’s exactly this that means he will be ideal.

The victims of the Grenfell tower blaze deserve the best kind of justiceCredit: Getty Images

That doesn’t mean he won’t deeply feel the magnitude of that horrifying day in June. How could he not?

Advertisement

So much of this inquiry is going to be immensely traumatic.

Working every day in the awful darkness of that tower’s shadow might make many — lawyers and non-lawyers alike — tumble into despair or anger.

Sir Martin will be an essential calm centre in the middle of so much churning grief.

And when the key piece of evidence is hidden in some ignored subclause, buried at the bottom of the last box of paperwork, he knows how to find it.

Advertisement

A judge like Sir Martin will shine an intense, unsparing light into every crevice and cranny of this tragedy.

The victims of Grenfell deserve no less.

SUMMING UP

Q. MY son, who has severe learning disabilities and limited mobility, fell when getting on a council bus, fracturing his arm and leg.

The bus was provided by a company that recently won the council contract and has a flight of stairs you have to negotiate to board the bus.

Prior to his accident, I raised concerns about the new buses and the council sent a risk assessor to watch my son getting on and off.

They concluded it was fine.

On the day of the accident, he fell despite being helped by myself and the driver.

He is now in a wheelchair full-time. I’ve had to buy a wheelchair-accessible vehicle and install a ramp in my house.

A “no win, no fee” firm agreed to take the case but then emailed to say it was not viable, as in their opinion there was nothing wrong with the bus.

Valerie, London

A What an appalling situation.

The firm you instructed has evidently carried out a preliminary legal assessment and taken the view your case is not worth pursuing.

This is, I’m afraid, a decent indication you are unlikely to succeed.

But ask ten lawyers a question and you can get ten different answers, so this is by no means the end.

Speak to your local Citizens Advice branch and the Law Society, who may be able to point you towards alternative legal help.

Mr Rinder regrets he cannot answer questions personally. Answers are intended as general guidance. They do not constitute legal advice and they are not a substitute for getting independent legal advice.



Got a question for Judge Rinder? Email judgerinder@mcb777.site


 

Advertisement