Jump directly to the content
Tested
SHORT OF STOUT

I’m a drinks expert and there’s one stout in Morrisons that’s as good as Guinness

Plus, Tesco and Lidl also have great tipples

GUINNESS has long been the go-to brand for stout sippers, but now the famous Dublin ale is facing competition as younger drinkers turn to different dark tipples.

Here, drinks expert Helena Nicklin gives marks out of five as she tests the latest contenders to the throne.

Helena Nicklin, photographed by Oliver Dixon for Sun Features - 25 Nov 2022. Byline photo
10
Drinks experts Helena Nicklin puts Guinness to the test against seven contendersCredit: Oliver Dixon
Irish Stout Build Series; Shutterstock ID 134567372; purchase_order: -; job: -; client: -; other: -
10
It comes as younger drinkers are turning away from the Dublin ale and trying out alternativesCredit: Shutterstock

Guinness Original Extra

£2.50, 500ml, Sainsbury’s

Guinness Original Extra Stout (in bottle) £2.50 500ml (£5/L), Sainsbury’s<br /> 4.2% ABV
10
A bottled Guinness is crisp, has bold bubbles, and delivers a yummy, yeasty fruitinessCredit: Supplied

GUINNESS Original from the bottle is a very different animal to the dreamy, draft style you get in cans and from the tap.

A bottled Guinness is crisper, has bolder bubbles and delivers a yummy, yeasty fruitiness.

Great for food pairing. Lively and lovely.

READ MORE TASTE TESTS

BIG CHEESE

I tasted all the supermarket Camemberts and winner was a tasty budget buy

CHOCS AWAY

I tested Caramac dupes and found a bar that tastes even BETTER

Score: 5/5

Kirkstall Tiramisu

£3, 440ml, Asda

Kirkstall Tiramisu Stout £3.00 440ml, ASDA (in stores only), (£6.81 /L)<br /> 5.5% ABV
10
The balance is off with this dessert-inspired tiramisu-themed tippleCredit: Supplied

THIS dessert-inspired tiramisu-themed tipple has a frothy head but smells less like the espresso and chocolate you’d expect and more like a green pepper.

There’s a bit of dusty coffee bean and a random note of amaretto, but no chocolate.

Most read in Money

Tesco shoppers fuming over yellow sticker receipt glitch
CHECKOUT THIS

Tesco shoppers fuming over yellow sticker receipt glitch

I bought home with £3k from overdraft - I had to use BUCKET for toilet but I love it
PROUD

I bought home with £3k from overdraft - I had to use BUCKET for toilet but I love it

Alcohol prices rise as higher tax and duties take effect
CHEERS

Alcohol prices rise as higher tax and duties take effect

Barclays confirms if bank customers hit by online outage will get compensation
BANK CHAOS

Barclays confirms if bank customers hit by online outage will get compensation

The balance is just off.

Score: 1/5

Brewdog Black Heart

£1.85, 440ml, Tesco

Brewdog Black Heart Stout £1.85 440ml (£4.20/L) Tesco Tesco<br /> 4.1% ABV
10
This choice is elegant, and there's a subtle cocoa bean nose and bitter kick when you glugCredit: Supplied

POP open the contemporary can and the ring pull sound is satisfying and the pour super silky.

With a decent head that’s creamy, not bubbly, it’s a little lighter than a pub-poured pint.

It’s elegant though – and there’s a subtle cocoa bean nose and bitter kick when you glug.

Score: 4/5

Vocation Double Tonka

£3.50, 440ml, Tesco

Vocation Double Tonka Frappe, Tonka Latte Stout, £3.50 440ml, Tesco, (£7.96/L) 8%<br /> ABV
10
This stout is a little strange, as it's less about latte and vanilla beans and more about gingerbread, dried cherry and burnt raisins soaked in brandyCredit: Supplied

THE tonka-themed ale tastes nothing like you might expect.

This stout is intensely strong and a little strange.

Less about latte and vanilla beans and more about gingerbread, dried cherry and burnt raisins soaked in brandy.

And at an 8 per cent abv, it’s extremely boozy.

Score: 3/5

Velvet

£1.50, 330ml, Asda

Velvet Stout £1.50 330ml (£4.55/L) ASDA, Link<br /> 5.3% ABV
10
The pour on this stout is more like a cola and the frothy head disappears quicklyCredit: Supplied

ASDA’S own stout is on the rustic side.

The pour is more like a cola and the frothy head disappears quickly.

It smells good, with an old-school malty, dark chocolate vibe.

In the mouth, it’s spritzy but rich and the tastes are concentrated. However, the flavours don’t linger.

Score: 2/5

Northern Monk Pumpkin

£3, 440ml, Tesco

Northern Monk Wasted Pumpkin Stout (also called Pumpkin Spiced Latte Porter)<br /> £3.00 440ml (£6.82/L),
10
Not exactly a natural nose with this stout's strong cinnamon and rose petal appeal, but it's more subtle than it smells - a worthy limited editionCredit: Supplied

A PORTER is a heavily hopped brown malt drink.

Not exactly a natural nose with its strong cinnamon and rose petal appeal but there’s real pumpkin flavour and aroma too.

Thankfully, it’s more subtle than it smells.

Not one for stout purists but a worthy limited edition.

Score: 3/5

Black Sheep Milk

£2.50, 500ml, Morrisons

Black Sheep Milk Stout £2.50 500ml (£3.70/L)
10
Immensely refreshing and drinkable, this stout from Morrisons is simply fabulousCredit: Supplied

MILK stouts are roasted malts topped up with lactose, which gives them a soothing sweetness.

This sip is creamy and cosy with the balance bang on – from the moreish, malted milk notes to the subtle bitterness at the end.

Immensely refreshing and drinkable, it’s fabulous.

Score: 5/5

Kakawa Chocolate

£1.85, 440ml, Lidl

Kakawa Chocolate Stout £1.85 440ml, (£4.20/L)
10
This ale has a head that hangs around for a little while - and it's well-pricedCredit: Supplied

HAS A decent head that hangs around a good while.

It smells like a bar of fruit and nut chocolate, although a little less sweet.

READ MORE SUN STORIES

sister love

Coleen Nolan breaks down in tears as Loose Women star says goodbye to Linda

GO-KART DEATH

Horror as teenager dies at popular go-karting centre

With a tiny touch of creaminess and a good, long length of flavour, this silky ale is a well-priced decent drop and worth a try for something different.

Score: 4/5

Topics
YOU MIGHT LIKE
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU
MORE FOR YOU