Jump directly to the content
It's Elementary

Sherlock and Spock are related… and five other fan theories about your favourite TV shows that will blow your mind

You may never look at these classic TV series the same again

SOME TV fans aren't satisfied with just watching their favourite show, over and over again.

In the age of box sets and Netflix, there are those who like to dig deeper and come up with theories gleaned from tiny clues that many would have missed.

But is Sherlock really related to Spock? Did Friends have a romantic link to Parks and Recreations? And is Bel Air really heaven to the Fresh Prince?

Here are the most popular fan theories doing the rounds.

 Sherlock and Spock are related

 Could Spock have come from the Holmes line?
6
Could Spock have come from the Holmes line?Credit: PA:Press Association

This is one to get all you sci-fi lovers excited.

The connection comes from a famous Sherlock quote from the Arthur Conan Doyle novels which is: “If you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth.”

This was quoted in Star Trek and then repeated in Benedict Cumberbatch's series Sherlock and, bizarrely, attributed to Spock.

But in Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country, Spock attributes the quote to "an ancestor of mine."

This makes him a direct descendent of Sherlock Holmes himself.

The One where Rachel dated someone from Parks and Recreation

 Rachel's former love life links these two shows
6
Rachel's former love life links these two showsCredit: NBC

Fans have come up with a theory that Friends and Parks and Recreations share the same universe and it’s backed up by one significant link.

During the Friends episode The One With All The Candy, Monica reveals Rachel (Jennifer Aniston) once dated a guy called Ben Wyatt.

Ben Wyatt is the name of Adam Scott's character on Parks and Recreation.

As both shows are NBC hits it’s possible that this was a deliberate secret link put in by the show’s writers.

The Rugrats aren’t real

 Was Angelica playing with imaginary friends?
6
Was Angelica playing with imaginary friends?Credit: BBC

This theory – which has been doing the rounds for a while – should definitely be filed under ‘bonkers.’

The story goes that the other babies are all a figment of Angelica’s imagination and she invented them to cope with her parent’s negligence.

In fact all her parents’ friends are childless because Chuckie and his mother died together, Tommy was stillborn and the DeVilles had an abortion, so Angelica invents twins since she doesn't know the gender of the baby.

The Fresh Prince of Bel Air is actually dead

 Di Fresh Prince Will (played by Will Smith) survive the fight in Philly?
6
Di Fresh Prince Will (played by Will Smith) survive the fight in Philly?Credit: Alamy

The theory goes that that Will is actually killed in the famous fight in Philadelphia, mentioned in the opening song and Bel Air is actually heaven.

The theory goes that Will is coming to terms with issues he's had with his estranged aunt and uncle who have also died.

However DJ Jazzy Jeff, who appeared in the show, debunked this myth saying: ““It’s just, that’s so far-fetched you just laugh.”

Walter White is actually Malcolm In the Middle as a grown up

 Frankie Muniz as Malcolm and Brian Cranston as Walter White
6
Frankie Muniz as Malcolm and Brian Cranston as Walter WhiteCredit: Alamy

Actor Brian Cranston played Malcolm’s dad Hal before becoming meth king Walter in Breaking Bad.

But is he just Malc as a man?

OK, so he’s not called Malcolm but fans have pointed to similarities between the two characters, saying they are both incredibly smart, brilliant at chemistry and great at manipulating others.

The name change is explained by the interval between the two shows when Malcolm grew up, moved away and changed his name. The name he chose was that of his beloved grandad from MITM – who happens to be called Walter.

Why Ash in Pokemon never grew up

 Pokemon star Ash stayed forever young
6
Pokemon star Ash stayed forever youngCredit: News Group Newspapers Ltd

The chief catcher in the classic series was chasing the elusive Pokemon for nearly 20 years – but was still only 10.

But the Pokemon fanbase think they have worked out the real reason why Ash never ages.

In the pilot episode, Ash sees the legendary Pokemon Ho-oh – who grants anyone who sees it “eternal happiness," according the the “Pokedex”.

Ash's idea of eternal happiness is to to forever be in pursuit of Pokemon so Ho-oh allows this to happen by keeping him forever young.

Topics