Facebook group which boasts 400,000 members, has since racked up more than 350 likes and hundreds of comments.
And it turns out the teeth detail is indeed an intentional part of the Christmas Nutcracker's design.
"Mine has teeth too lol didn't notice till you said", gasped another social media user.
I transformed my council house into a pinkmas Christmas paradise with Asda & B&M buys - trolls say it's 'too cluttered'Someone else wrote: "Me running over to check mine then franticly pushing his beard back down because WHAT ARE THOSE?"
A third said: "Think mine went to Turkey least they are straight but it’s a no from me.
"Imagine seeing them in the dark with just the lights from the Christmas tree on them."
Meanwhile, a fourth claimed: "I will never be able to look at mine in the same way now."
And others were quick to joke that the Nutcracker's toothy grin reminded them of Turkey Teeth.
"Nutcracker's been to Turkey", one said.
A second echoed: "More like Nutcracker needs to go to Turkey. You'd think they'd at least make them look nice not just as a child has scribbled it."
"Turkey teeth for turkey nuts", echoed a third person.
It comes after shoppers were left fuming over a mistake on a Christmas decoration that "takes 20 tries to spot".
The fun Winter Charm Metal Standing Street Sign gives directions to Santa's workshop, elf village and reindeer stables, and would look perfect indoors or outdoors.
The free-standing decoration was originally priced at £6.99 in Home Bargains but was slashed to just £2.99 over the error.